Research

Preventive Force Conference

May 25, 2005 - May 27, 2005
THE HOOVER INSTITUTION AND STANFORD INSTITUTE FOR INTERNATIONAL STUDIES


The 2002 National Security Strategy (NSS) called for a shift in objectives and methods in dealing with threats to national security from an emphasis on law enforcement to prevention based in part on the use of force. The NSS proposed that, in addition to continued reliance on diplomacy, economic sanctions, and other methods short of the use of force, the U.S. should resort to force in order to prevent grave dangers where necessary, in some cases even when the threat they pose is not imminent, and despite the absence of Security Council approval. These positions raise important and unsettled issues, which the sponsoring organizations propose to consider at a meeting on Preventive Force, to be held from May 25th to May 27th, 2005, at the headquarters of the Hewlett Foundation in Menlo Park. It is being planned and organized by the Hoover Institution, in cooperation with the Hewlett Foundation and the Stanford Institute for International Studies. The meeting on Preventive Force will bring together a small group of practitioners, scholars, and officials experienced in the relevant fields of international security affairs to discuss the following issues among others: the need to consider using preventive force; the nature of preventive (as opposed to preemptive) force; the dangers of relying on preventive force as part of a national security strategy; the standards by which resort to preventive force should be governed, if its use is ever appropriate; and the principles and measures that might if adopted reduce the need to resort to preventive force. In addition to panels and speakers on these subjects, the meeting will include a televised session for the PBS program "Uncommon Knowledge," at which some of the participants will offer perspectives on the utility and wisdom of relying on preventive force as an avowed element of U.S. national security, and on the role of the Security Council in controlling such decisions. We will be joined by scholars from the Brookings Institution and members of the Princeton Project on National Security, sponsored by Princeton's Woodrow Wilson School of Public and International Affairs. We appreciate their help in preparing a program for the initial meetings. We will also have the participation of Stanford's Center for International Security and Cooperation.


Agenda

CONFERENCE AGENDA

DAY ONE, WEDNESDAY MAY 25

6:30–9:00 PM

Reception and Dinner for Participants
Bechtel Conference Center, Encina Hall, Stanford University
 
Welcome
JOHN HENNESSY, President, Stanford University
 


 

DAY TWO, THURSDAY MAY 26

 

CONFERENCE
The William and Flora Hewlett Foundation, Menlo Park

8:30–9:00 AM

Breakfast

9:00–9:15 AM

Greeting and Introduction
PAUL BREST, President, The Hewlett Foundation (5 minutes)
ABRAHAM D. SOFAER, (5 minutes)

9:15–11:00 AM

PANEL 1: Current Threats to National Security
Chair:
   SCOTT SAGAN
Participants:
   MICHAEL RADU (terrorism)
   SIDNEY DRELL (nuclear proliferation)
   CHRIS CHYBA (biological weapons)

11:00–11:15 AM

Coffee

11:15–12:30 PM

PANEL 2: Preventive Force and its Dangers
Chair:
   DAVID HOLLOWAY
Participants:
   COL. DANIEL ZAJAC (history and rationale)
   JAMES STEINBERG (dangers and difficulties)

12:30–1:30 PM

Lunch

1:30–3:00 PM

PANEL 3: Law, Legitimacy & Preventive Force
Chair:
   ANNE-MARIE SLAUGHTER
Participants:
   GERHARD CASPER (law & legitimacy)
   ALLEN WEINER (adequacy of current norms)
   ABRAHAM D. SOFAER (inadequacy of current norms)

3:00–3:15 PM

Coffee

3:15–5:00 PM

PANEL 4: Emerging Norms: Alternate Views
Chair:
   JOHN IKENBERRY
Participants:
   IVO DAALDER
   STEPHEN STEDMAN

6:00–6:30 PM

Reception
Mark Hatfield Court, Stauffer Auditorium
Herbert Hoover Memorial Building
Stanford University

6:30–7:15 PM

Pre-dinner Program
Welcoming Remarks
JOHN RAISIAN, Director, the Hoover Institution
 
PANEL FOR UNCOMMON KNOWLEDGE:
Preventive Force and International Security
Participants will watch the taped PBS program for Uncommon Knowledge.
 
Moderator:
   PETER ROBINSON
Participants:
   VICTOR D. HANSON
   ANNE-MARIE SLAUGHTER
   STEPHEN STEDMAN

7:15–9:00 PM

Dinner Stauffer Auditorium


QUICK LINKS:
CONTACT US
DIRECTIONS

SEARCH:

TOOLS:




Hoover Institution Homepage News Get Involved Search About Hoover Library & Archives Research Task Forces Fellows Publications Multimedia