The Impeachment Of A Former President, With Richard Epstein, Andrew McCarthy, And John Yoo

The second impeachment trial of Donald Trump begins on February 9, 2021, but a fierce debate as to the constitutionality of trying a former president in this manner has been ongoing in the legal community for weeks. To bring some possible clarity and resolution to the matter, we assembled three of best and most cogent legal minds we know: Professor John Yoo of Berkeley Law School, Professor Richard Epstein of the University of Chicago and New York University School of Law, and Andrew McCarthy, former federal prosecutor and a legal commentator for National Review and Fox News. Two of our guests argue that a former president of the United States can be tried; one guest takes the other side of the argument. We won’t reveal who takes what angle, but we can say that both points of view get a thorough airing. We leave it to our audience to determine the winning argument.

Recorded on February 8, 2021

To view the transcript of this conversation, click here.

Cast

Richard A. Epstein

Richard A. Epstein

John Yoo

John Yoo

Andrew McCarthy

Andrew McCarthy

Related

Thomas Sowell’s Impact On Economics

How Thomas Sowell used economic history, evidence, and storytelling to challenge conventional wisdom and bring economics to the public.

October 1, 2026

What Thucydides Can Teach Us About Politics And War

Everyone quotes Thucydides—but are we getting him right? Historian Andrew Novo joins Andrew Roberts to explore what the chronicler of Athens and Sparta really tells us about war, democracy, ambition, and human nature. 

September 8, 2026

‘Reclaiming Liberal Education In America’

This book features 40 RealClearPolitics columns that I wrote between 2014 and 2025. Each chapter provides a snapshot of the plight of liberal education in America. Together, they form a short history of liberal education’s decline and provide a concise case for, and sketch measures essential to, reclaiming it.*

September 27, 2026