Incentives matter, sure. But what should you do when following the incentives means quietly participating in something wrong? Psychologist Adam Mastroianni argues that obeying bad incentives—shading a headline for clicks, keeping the found wallet because no one's watching—is "loser behavior," a surrender of the hardest and most human task: figuring out right from wrong for yourself. In this wide-ranging EconTalk conversation, he and Russ Roberts explore Le Guin's Omelas, the "big fish" you glimpse that could upend your whole life, and Charles Sumner's near-fatal courage. They wrestle with whether good incentives or good people matter more, why lavish academic salaries may attract exactly the wrong scholars, and the moral lessons of marriage.

Listen to the episode here.

ABOUT THE SPEAKER

Adam Mastroianni is an experimental psychologist and the author of Experimental History, a popular science Substack, and the coming soon book The Strangest Idea in the World (Penguin, 2027). His research explores how people perceive social change, how psychology can become a more paradigmatic science, and why important discoveries often take so long to emerge.

Mastroianni holds degrees from Harvard, Oxford, and Princeton. His work has appeared in The New York Times and The Atlantic and has been featured on late-night television. He has also taught and performed improv comedy around the world and once placed second on a British cooking show. He is originally from Monroeville, Ohio.

RELATED SOURCES

Cast

Russ Roberts

Russ Roberts

Related

VIDEO

Should We Regulate AI (Before It's Too Late)?

Artificial intelligence could become one of the most consequential drivers of productivity and economic growth in a generation. Yet concerns about job displacement, misinformation, and political disruption have prompted calls to regulate the technology before its effects are fully understood. History shows that major innovations disrupt existing industries while creating new forms of work and enterprise that policymakers rarely anticipate. Premature regulation risks entrenching established firms, limiting competition, and expanding government influence over information. The challenge is to address genuine harms while preserving the freedom and experimentation that allow innovation to advance.

VIDEO

Is Minimum Wage A Dead End?

Minimum wage policy is intended to increase earnings for low-wage workers and reduce poverty. Evidence from state-level increases, however, shows that businesses may respond by changing how many people they employ, how many hours they offer, whom they hire, and how much work they automate. Workers who remain employed may earn more per hour, but others may lose income or job opportunities, while many of those who benefit do not live in poor households. The Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC) directs support toward low-income working families without putting other workers’ jobs or hours at risk.

Articles

Money and Power: Historical Lessons for Stablecoins and U.S. Dollar Dominance

Economics Working Paper 26126

September 8, 2026