Should Speech That Offends Be Prohibited?

Published: May 1, 2017

Speech that attempts to persuade is broadly protected under free speech, even if some people find it offensive. What some find offensive, others may find persuasive. A commitment to free speech inevitably means protecting the rights of people whose speech is deeply offensive to many, but a permissive environment leads to fewer rights being violated and ultimately, a freer world.

Discussion Questions

  1. Are there any circumstances in which offensive speech is prohibited?
  2. Can you counteract offensive speech through persuasive speech?
  3. Allowing offensive speech means some people who hold views that are widely offensive will be allowed to speak. What are the benefits of a system that protects groups like that? What are the costs?

Cast

Richard A. Epstein

Richard A. Epstein

Related

Articles

The American Experiment: Blending Liberty And Virtue From The First

The American experiment in ordered liberty assumes that elections will come and go but that amid changing circumstances the nation’s fundamental principles will endure – providing continuity, ballast, and guidance – and citizens will persist in exercising their rights and performing their duties reasonably. 

October 12, 2026

Articles

Bo French’s Rhetoric Misrepresents The GOP

[Subscription Required] The candidate’s anti-Asian comments don’t reflect how most Republicans think.

October 9, 2026

Videos

The Great Fertility Collapse With Jesús Fernández-Villaverde

For the first time in human history, we're not having enough children to keep the world's population from falling. 

October 12, 2026