Published: October 17, 2016

If You Want To Help People, Is Socialism The Answer?

Many Americans believe socialism to be a form of social kindness by the government. But true socialism isn’t a social safety net. It is when the government controls most prices, businesses, property, and other aspects of economic life. The historical record of socialism has been wrecked or stagnating economies and flagrant human rights violations. The truth borne of a hundred years of hard experience is that people do not prosper in socialist countries.

Discussion Questions

  1. What distinguishes a socialist economy from a freer economy with a large welfare state?
  2. Why don’t socialist economies prosper or feature new products or globally competitive companies?

Cast

David Davenport

David Davenport

Milton Friedman

Milton Friedman

Thomas Sowell

Thomas Sowell

Allan H. Meltzer

Allan H. Meltzer

Why is socialism gaining so much popularity?

Today, more than a third of Americans say they support socialism - but do we actually understand what socialism is?

Many younger Americans view socialism as a form of social kindness – the government helping people who can't take care of themselves.

The problem is that this understanding is actually a misunderstanding.

True socialism ISN’T a social safety net - it's when the government OWNS most businesses and controls most aspects of economic life - like prices, salaries, and where people can work.

Supporters often point to Denmark. But, Denmark isn’t a socialist country – it’s a free-market economy with a large welfare state.

If we want to see what socialism truly looks like, we need to look to Cuba and Venezuela.

The Cuban government still owns most of the property in the country, closely regulates what jobs can exist in the private sector, and dictates salaries for most other jobs.

In Venezuela, the state has blocked most imports, taken over many businesses, and set wages and prices, leading to a shortage of basic goods like toilet paper and common medications.

In both countries, the results are wrecked or stagnating economies and flagrant human rights violations.

The truth borne of a hundred years of hard experience is that people do not prosper in socialist countries.

It’s imperative to understand what socialism really means and review the lessons of history, before supporting a system that leads to widespread poverty and suffering.

Related

Videos

California’s War On Wealth—And America’s War On Terror

Is the progressive dream of wealth taxes soon to be reality – or a fiscal and economic nightmare – should voters approve Proposition 40 and a one-time 5% tax on the holdings of the Golden State’s billionaire class? And 25 years after one of the darkest days in the republic’s history, what is the legacy of the 9/11 attacks on America?

September 9, 2026

Articles

Letter #9: The Test Of A Nation

A Labor Day letter to America.

September 7, 2026

Articles

A Better Way To Reform Head Start

Trump proposes to convert it into block grants. What it needs is a single-minded focus on preparing kids for kindergarten.

September 4, 2026