Why a Universal Basic Income Won't Work

Published September 21, 2021

Some people believe a universal basic income (UBI) is the next step in anti-poverty policy, but a UBI is a dangerous departure from centuries of welfare policy. By imposing no obligations on recipients, the UBI gives recipients less of a reason to work, develop their skills, or improve their situation in life. This failure to understand a key aspect of human nature makes the UBI a destructive policy for the very recipients it is intended to help.

Discussion Questions:

  1. What motivates people to improve their skills or their situation in life?
  2. What assumptions does a UBI make about human nature?

Additional Resources

  • Read “The Economic Impact of a Universal Basic Income,” by John Cogan and Daniel Heil. Available here.
  • Watch “The Reality of Universal Basic Income” on PolicyEd. Available here.
  • Read “The Case Against a Basic Income Guarantee,” by David Henderson. Available here.

Cast

John F. Cogan

John F. Cogan

Daniel Heil

Daniel Heil

Related

Working Papers

The Anatomy of Capital Returns over the Very Long Run: Germany, 1465–2025

Economics Working Paper 26128

November 6, 2026

Articles

Data Center Siting And Community Opposition

Where data centers locate to fuel the growth of artificial intelligence (AI) is of burgeoning political importance with economic and environmental implications. We highlight local factors associated with siting and opposition.

November 3, 2026

Event

Money and Power: Historical Lessons for Stablecoins and U.S Dollar Dominance

The Hoover Institution Economic Policy Working Group hosted “Money and Power: Historical Lessons for Stablecoins and U.S Dollar Dominance” with Michael D. Bordo, the Duncan Stewart Distinguished Visiting Fellow at the Hoover Institution.

April 23, 2026