Can Deliberative Discussions Heal Political Divides?

Published December 13, 2022

A national experiment called “American in One Room” brought together more than 500 randomly selected voters from around the country for a weekend of guided deliberation. Those who participated were more likely in the short run to moderate their political attitudes and more likely in the long run to engage in civil society.

Discussion Questions:

  1. Why do you think people ultimately went back to their old views after the study?
  2. Does this study show a way to reduce polarization permanently? What do you think?

Additional Resources:

  • Read “Is Deliberation an Antidote to Extreme Partisan Polarization? Reflections on ‘America in One Room,’” by James Fishkin, Alice Siu, Larry Diamond, and Norman Bradburn. Available here.
  • Watch “Morris Fiorina on Why Political Parties Have Polarized,” with Morris Fiorina. Available here.
  • Watch “Unstable Majorities,” with Morris Fiorina. Available here.

Cast

Valentin Bolotnyy

Valentin Bolotnyy

Related

Articles

“What Do We Do Now?”

This final line in a long-ago movie about a fictional California race seems to fit our real, post-election Sacramento. The capital mood is stranger than fiction, with its outgoing governor who won’t cede the spotlight and a governor-elect who’s short on specifics.

November 12, 2026

Videos

“Extinction Level Event”: Jonah Goldberg On The Midterm Elections

Jonah Goldberg discusses the aftermath of this week’s midterm election in the US – a shocking repudiation of the Trump presidency and arguably the harshest setback for Republican candidates nationwide since 1974’s Watergate backlash. 

November 6, 2026

Articles

The Dawn Of The Post-Trump Era

Donald Trump remains in the White House, but the midterms have made him a lame duck.

November 5, 2026