Poorly Targeted: Student Loan Forgiveness

Published May 25, 2021

Student loan debt won’t go away on its own, but untargeted forgiveness is not the answer. Across-the-board loan cancelation would undermine existing forgiveness programs and would primarily benefit well-off Americans. Targeted student loan assistance is a better way to benefit the people who actually need the most help.

Discussion Questions

  1. What effect would across-the-board student loan cancelation have on current forgiveness programs?
  2. Why is targeted assistance more effective than untargeted loan forgiveness?

Additional Resources

  • Read “Massive Student Loan Forgiveness Would Be a Lost Opportunity to Help Needy Americans,” by Michael Petrilli via USA Today. Available here.
  • Read “Avoid the Pitfalls of Student Loan Forgiveness,” by Richard Epstein via Defining Ideas. Available here.
  • Read “Is Student Debt Too Great?” by Gary Becker. Available here.

Cast

Michael J. Petrilli

Michael J. Petrilli

Related

Videos

Eyck Freymann On Why Taiwan Matters

Why does Taiwan matter to the United States, and what would it take to prevent a war with China?

November 16, 2026

Articles

The Global Wealth Tax ‘Movement’ Just Hit A Wall In California

Tuesday’s election results delivered a verdict on the wealth tax movement: It has hit a wall, and the wall was in California.

November 12, 2026

Articles

Immaculate Disinflation

Today I’m going to talk about immaculate disinflation — lower inflation without recession.

November 11, 2026