Published November 23, 2021

Many Americans argue that an isolationist policy would be better for the United States, and they are not the first to do so. In the late 1930s, the America First Committee strongly opposed US involvement in European conflicts. But as history shows, neutrality and isolationism have never been options for the nation. The United States must maintain a limited but strategic presence around the world to protect the most vulnerable populations and to preserve freedom both at home and abroad.

Discussion Questions:

  1. Why is it essential for America to remain engaged abroad?
  2. What examples throughout history show the consequences of American isolationist policy?

Additional Resources

  • Read “‘America First’ Then and Now,” by Kiron Skinner. Available here.
  • Watch “Projecting the Future of US Foreign Policy,” with Kiron Skinner. Available here.
  • Read “The Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse: Populism, Isolationism, Nativism, and Protectionism,” by Condoleezza Rice. Available here.

More from UnArchived: Lessons From the Past

Rethinking Decisive Force in Modern Warfare

Rethinking Decisive Force in Modern Warfare

Tactical Victories. Strategic Success

Tactical Victories. Strategic Success

Tactical Victories. Strategic Success

Tactical Victories. Strategic Success

Why Federalism Matters

Why Federalism Matters

Modern Technology. Human Warfare

Modern Technology. Human Warfare

Proxy Wars

Proxy Wars

Why Russia Fights

Why Russia Fights

Deterrence in Defense of Taiwan

Deterrence in Defense of Taiwan

Russian Way of War

Russian Way of War

NATO's Enduring Value

NATO's Enduring Value

More Like This

The Lapsed Atheist: Charles Murray Makes The Case For God

The Lapsed Atheist: Charles Murray Makes The Case For God

Norway: Defense And Diplomacy In The High North And Beyond

Norway: Defense And Diplomacy In The High North And Beyond

Thomas Sowell Legacy: A Conversation with Justice Clarence Thomas

Thomas Sowell Legacy: A Conversation with Justice Clarence Thomas

Can AI Libel You? The Robby Starbuck Case

Can AI Libel You? The Robby Starbuck Case

Jan Karski

Jan Karski

Complicated Legacy: Jay Bhattacharya On Fauci, RFK, And Vaccines

Complicated Legacy: Jay Bhattacharya On Fauci, RFK, And Vaccines

AI-Powered Business Formation

AI-Powered Business Formation

Iraq: Reform And The Fight For Sovereignty

Iraq: Reform And The Fight For Sovereignty

Securing the Future of Semiconductors

Securing the Future of Semiconductors

Tom Siebel On Education, Reinvention, And The AI Revolution

Tom Siebel On Education, Reinvention, And The AI Revolution

Related

Articles

Abbas Milani: Stanford's Director Of Iranian Studies On Whether There's A Path To End The War

Hoover Institution fellow Abbas Milani talks about why more Iranians are fleeing their country and whether there's a realistic path to end the US-Iran war.

August 14, 2026

Articles

Critical Choices In The Indo-Pacific

All the security variables—alliances, weapons, nuclear moves—converge on US-China relations.

August 12, 2026

Articles

What About The Bomb? Part 3

If Hirohito Was So Concerned about Preserving His Dynasty and Sparing His Subjects from Suffering, Why Didn’t He Intervene Sooner to End the War?

August 12, 2026