livefromhooverdc_banner_v2.jpg

learninginthefastlane.jpg

The Hoover Institution hosted "Is Advanced Placement Good for Everyone? A Discussion with Partisans and Doubters" on Monday, December 9, 2019 from 11:30 AM – 1:30 PM EST.

Learning in the Fast Lane: The Past, Present, and Future of Advanced Placement (Princeton 2019), a new book by Chester Finn and Andrew Scanlan, tells the story of the Advanced Placement (AP) program, widely regarded as the gold standard for academic rigor in American high schools. AP is enormous today—22,000 participating schools, 3 million students a year taking 5 million exams—and embraced and praised by many, but not by all. Some elite private schools have turned against it while some educators and policymakers favor dual enrollment in its many forms as a better alternative for kids. Advanced Placement faces other challenges, too, including curricular culture wars, credit denial by prominent universities, and the difficulty of infusing its rigor into more schools.

Featured participants are:

  • Clara Haskell Botstein of the Bard Early College High Schools to explain the benefits of dual credit and early-college programs for high-school students.
  • Peter Gow of the Independent Curriculum Group and One Schoolhouse to explain why dozens of high-status prep schools are choosing not to offer AP-designated courses.
  • Trevor Packer, who heads Advanced Placement at the College Board, to explain today’s AP program, important recent changes and additions to it, and its merits going forward.
  • Jack Smith, superintendent of schools in Montgomery County MD, to offer a veteran practitioner’s perspective on how AP (and IB) function in a large, diverse school system and explain why that system is working to expand their reach.

Chester Finn moderated the conversation.

Participants

Clara Haskell Botstein, Associate Vice President of Bard Early Colleges

Peter Gow, Independent Curriculum Group Resource Director at One Schoolhouse

Trevor Packer, Senior Vice President and Director of Advanced Placement at the College Board

Jack Smith, Superintendent of Montgomery County Public Schools

Moderator

Chester E. Finn, Jr., Distinguished Senior Fellow and President Emeritus, Thomas B. Fordham Institute and co-author of Learning in the Fast Lane


Watch the livestream

Upcoming Events

Wednesday, February 18, 2026
Class Of University Students Using Laptops In Lecture stock photo
What Counts As Success? Assessing The Impact Of Civics In Higher Ed
The Alliance for Civics in the Academy hosts "What Counts as Success? Assessing the Impact of Civics in Higher Ed" with Trygve Throntveit, Rachel… Hoover Institution, Stanford University
Wednesday, March 4, 2026
Classroom iStock-1254051142.jpg
How Can Universities Strengthen Civic Education in K–12 Schools?
The Alliance for Civics in the Academy hosts "How Can Universities Strengthen Civic Education in K–12 Schools?" with Jennifer McNabb, Joshua Dunn,… Hoover Institution, Stanford University
Wednesday, March 4, 2026
Judicial Importance, Independence, And Legitimacy In Polarized Times
The Center for Revitalizing American Institutions (RAI) invites you to join us for the next webinar—co-sponsored by the Stanford Constitutional Law… Hoover Institution, Stanford University
overlay image